Explore the

MENUS

Dinner Menu

Peterson’s is well renowned for its prime steaks, fresh seafood, house-made desserts, award-winning wines, outstanding service and distinguished atmosphere. Please don’t hesitate to ask our staff for anything you may need. We hope your dining experience with us is memorable and exceeds all expectations.

~Joe Peterson

Oysters of the Day - East & West Coast Varieties Fresh Daily Cocktail Sauce, Horseradish, Mignonette

Chilled Seafood Platter - Gulf Shrimp Cocktail, Select Oysters, Alaskan King Crab, Lump Crab Cocktail, Sesame Seaweed Salad

Wine Menu

Peterson’s offers an award-winning wine library of 400 + labels with an ongoing emphasis on current trends and a broad range for each varietal.

We are 1 of only 3 Indy area restaurants to receive numerous “Best of” awards from Wine Spectator. Restaurants who receive “Best of Award of Excellence” honors are notably described as a destination for “serious wine lovers”, with a, “…deep commitment to wine, both in the cellar and through their service team.”

View “Wines by the Glass” and download our complete wine list below:

1240

Varietal Bin Wine Glass Bottle
Sparkling   Maschio, Italy – Prosecco 10 187ml
  Moët et Chandon, Brut, Champagne, France,187ml, NV 23 187ml
  Moët et Chandon, Brut Rosé, Champagne, France, 187ml, NV 27 187ml
  Mumm, Napa Valley, California 12 187ml
Moscato 5011 Bricco Riella, Moscato d’Asti, Italy 11 38
Riesling 6025 Trefethen Family Vineyards, Oak Knoll District, Napa Valley, California 11 40
Sauvignon Blanc 6029 Frog’s Leap Winery, Napa Valley 12 45
Rosé 6087 Chateau Puech-Haut, Languedoc, France 12 45
Pinot Grigio 6125 Terlato Vineyards, Fruili Colli Orientali, DOC, Italy 11 40
Chardonnay 6098 Red Mare, Dutton Ranch, Napa Valley 16 60
Pinot Noir 7006 Bouchaine, Carneros, Napa Valley 16 55
Merlot 2164 “R” Collection, Raymond Vineyards, Napa Valley 12 45
Cabernet Sauvignon 3081 Rutherford Ranch, Napa Valley, California 12 45
Malbec 3008 La Posta, “Paulucci Vineyards” Mendozza, Argentina 11 40
Syrah 4006 Jigar Tollini Vienyard, Mendocino, California 14 50
Tempranillo 1008 Iturria, Toro, Spain 14 48

Bar Menu

House-Cured & Smoked BaconSweet Cherry & Cola Glaze

Crispy CalamariNapa Slaw, Ginger Orange Chili Sauce

 Peterson’s MeatballsPeterson Family Recipe, Brown Sugar BBQ, Grilled Herb Crostinis

Mussels & Frites – White Wine Broth with Garlic, Lemon, Tomato, Herbs

Prime Rib Egg Rolls – Wasabi Aioli, Scallions, White Cheddar, Soy Jus

Steak & FritesChuck Strip, Arugula, Shallot Chive Demi

Portobello Fries –  Rosemary Parmesan Panko Crust, Horseradish Cream

Chef’s Tater Tots – Smoked Gouda, Jalapeño, Bacon, Beer Cheese Sauce

Mini Lobster Roll – Dill, Tarragon, Parsley, Honey Crisp Apples

Crispy CalamariNapa Slaw, Ginger Orange Chili Sauce

Peterson's Prime BurgerServed with Peterson's Hand-Cut Fries 

Chef's Charcuterie Local Selection of Meats & Cheeses

Prime Rib French DipWhite Cheddar, Crispy Onions, Horseradish Cream, Au Jus 

Gunthorp Farms Breaded Pork TenderloinCider Brined & Applewood Smoked, Spicy Mustard, Pickles, Lettuce

Prime BurgerHerb Butter, Caramelized Onions

1910 PAMAPendleton 1910 Rye, PAMA Liqueur, Mint Syrup, Lemon Juice

Fall Fashioned High West Double Rye, Apple Cinnamon Demerara, Molasses & Angostura Bitters

WildflowerGin, Heirloom Crème de Flora, Lime, Mint Syrup

InzaneityDon Julio Reposado, Del Maguey Vida Mezcal, Agave, Chocolate Bitters

Ol' GrannyVanilla Bulleit, High West Campfire, Apple Cinnamon Bitters

Doc Holliday High West Double Rye, Huckleberry Mint Syrup, Lemon, Cardamom Bitters

Cherry TartPapa's Pilar Dark Rum, Tattersall Sour Cherry, Molasses Bitters

Night MuleKetel One Citroen, Tattersall Lime Crema, Lemon, Orange Bitters, Ginger Beer

 Pinetini Our SignatureFresh Golden Pineapple, Orange Vodka Infusion

The Maestro Muddled Jalapeño & Basil, Dobel Tequila, Agave Nectar, Lime Juice

Jack FrostHanger One Vodka, White Chocolate Godiva, Vanilla Lavender Syrup

RhumbrellaBacardi 8, Pilar Blonde, Giffard Passionfruit, Lime, Orange, Orgeat, Mole Bitters

REGIONAL CRAFTS

Bell's Two Hearted IPA

Sun King Osiris Pale Ale

Sun King Sunlight Cream Ale

Sun King Wee Mac Scottish Ale

IMPORTED

Amstel Light Lager

Buckler, NA

Corona Extra

Corona Premier

Heineken

Heineken 0.0 NA

DOMESTIC

Blue Moon

Budweiser

Bud Light

Coors Light

Miller Lite

Michelob Ultra

Rotating Crafts

Single Malt Scotch

Balvenie Double Wood

Balvenie Caribbean Cask

Balvenie Port Wood

Cragganmore 12 Yr

Dalmore 12 Yr

Dalwhinnie 15 Yr

Glenfiddich 12 Yr

Glenfiddich 18 Yr

Glenfiddich 30 Yr

Glenlivet 12 Yr

Glenmorangie 10 Yr

Glenmorangie 25 Yr

Lagavulin 16 Yr

Laphroaig 10 Yr

Macallan 12 Yr

Macallan 18 Yr

Oban 14 Yr

Small Batch Bourbon & Whiskey

1792 Small Batch

Basil Hayden's

Blanton's

Booker's

Bulleit

Eagle Rare

High West Campfire

High West Double Rye

Knob Creek

Maker's Mark

Rowan's Creek

Stranahan's

Stranahan’s Diamond Peak

Tin Cup

Whistle Pig 12 Yr

Willet Pot Still Reserve

Woodford Reserve

Premium Blended Scotch

Chivas Regal

Johnnie Walker

Black

Blue

Odyssey

Platinum

Red

Select Casks Rye

Irish Whiskey

Bushmills - White, Red, Black

Tullamore Dew

Cognac & Armagnac 

Courvoisier VS

Courvoisier VSOP

Courvoisier XO

Hardy Perfection

Hennessy VS

Hennessy VSOP Privilege

Hennessy XO

Kelt VSOP

Kelt XO

Maison Gelas V.S.O.P Bas Armagnac

Maison Gelas 8 Yr Selection

Martell Blue Swift VSOP

Remy Martin 1738

Remy Martin Louis XIII

Remy Martin VSOP

Remy Martin XO

Port, Madeira & Sherry 

B.R. Cohn Cabernet Port Olive Hill Estate

Dow's LBV Ruby Port

Graham's Tawny Port 20 Yr

Warre's Otima Port 10 Yr

Midnight Cellars Gemini Port

Taylor Fladgate LBV Ruby Port

Vintage Tawny Port

Sandeman Rainwater Madeira

Sandeman Armada Cream Sherry

VGS Chateau Potelle Zinie Late Harvest

COFFEE DRINKS

Cafe CocoMalibu Rum, Godiva Dark, Nocello 
"The Dude"Kahlua, White Chocolate Godiva, Vanilla Vodka
Irish AngelFrangelico, Bailey's Irish Cream  
Peterson's CoffeeNocello, Godiva White Chocolate 

PORT, MADEIRA & SHERRY

B.R. Cohn Cabernet Port Olive Hill Estate

Dow's LBV Ruby Port

Graham's Tawny Port 20 Yr

Warre's Otima Port 10 Yr

Midnight Cellars Gemini Port

Taylor Fladgate LBV Ruby Port

Vintage Tawny Port

Sandeman Rainwater Madeira

Sandeman Armada Cream Sherry

VGS Chateau Potelle Zinie Late Harvest

DESSERT WINES

Dolce by Far Niente

Inniskillin Ice Wine

Trentadue Chocolate Amore

COGNAC & ARMAGNAC

Courvoisier VS

Courvoisier VSOP

Courvoisier XO

Hardy Perfection

Hennessy VS

Hennessy VSOP Privilege

Hennessy XO

Kelt VSOP

Kelt XO

Maison Gelas 8 Yr Selection

Maison Gelas VSOP Bar Armagnac

Martell Blue Swift VSOP

Remy Martin 1738

Remy Martin Louis XIII

Remy Martin VSOP

Remy Martin XO

Treat yourself to the best of the top shelf with a luxury pour!

Hardy Perfection Series Air

Often referred to as “the world’s oldest unblended cognac”, Hardy Perfection is an exceptional complex Cognac dating back to the 1870’s. With strong notes of chocolate and coffee, it has a mellow mouth that is round and smooth but not heady. The nose is particularly persistent and aromatic with a typical final of cigar box and nutmeg. The grape variety is Colombard.

Remy Martin Louis XIII

A legendary Cognac from the prestigious house of Remy Martin, Louis XIII was first created in 1874. It is blended from more than a 1,000 “eaux de vie” aged between 40 to 100 years. Its grapes are grown in the Grande Champagne district, part of the French cognac region. Known to be a favorite choice of Elton John and Christian Dior, Winston Churchill celebrated his 1951 election with Louis XIII.

Johnny Walker Odyssey

Johnny Walker’s Odyssey is a rare Triple Malt made from three extraordinary Single Malts. Blended and married together in oak casks to enhance the layering of flavors, Odyssey’s russet-red hue is full of rich tannins. It’s slightly sweet, slightly smoky smooth flavors will linger long after your last sip.

Grand Marnier Quintessence

Grand Marnier’s Quintessence is made from the private reserves of the Marnier Lapostolle family. The most premium offering in the Grande Cuvée Collection, Quintessence is double-distilled with wild tropical orange essence and aged in French oak casks to produce the perfect “quintessential” taste.

Glenmorangie 25 Years Old

The rarest and oldest member of the Glenmorangie family, this is a single malt of notable class and intensity. Full bodied and sumptuous, the Glenmorangie 25 Years Old is the real embodiment of our continued dedication to perfection. Matured in a range of casks including American white oak, Oloroso sherry casks and French Burgundy casks before being blended back together in exact quantities, the Glenmorangie Quarter Century is complex, bursting with deep flavors, and a perfect testimony to our knowledge and experience.

Glenfiddich 30 Year Old

An exceptional expression that has spent at least 30 years in Spanish Oloroso and American bourbon oak. Every cask nosed, selected and married by our Malt Master. For the finest balance of hearty oak and honeyed warmth. A 30 Year Old with deep, layered flavors and a masterful finish. Handcrafted by the expert.