Explore the

MENUS

Dinner Menu

Peterson’s is well renowned for its prime steaks, fresh seafood, house-made desserts, award-winning wines, outstanding service and distinguished atmosphere. Please don’t hesitate to ask our staff for anything you may need. We hope your dining experience with us is memorable and exceeds all expectations.

~Joe Peterson

Oysters of the Day - East & West Coast Varieties Fresh Daily Cocktail Sauce, Horseradish, Mignonette

Wine Menu

award 2022
award-2023

Peterson’s offers an award-winning wine library of 400 + labels with an ongoing emphasis on current trends and a broad range for each varietal.

We are 1 of only 4 Indiana restaurants to receive the Best of Award of Excellence from Wine Spectator and the only one in the Indianapolis area. Restaurants who receive “Best of Award of Excellence” honors are notably described as a destination for “serious wine lovers”, with a, “…deep commitment to wine, both in the cellar and through their service team.”

View “Wines by the Glass” and download our complete wine list below:

Varietal Bin Wine Glass Bottle
Sparkling   Maschio, Italy – Prosecco 10 187ml
  Chandon, Napa Valley, California 15 187ml
  Moët et Chandon, Brut or Rosé, Champagne, France, 187ml, NV 30 187ml
Moscato 5011 Bricco Riella, Moscato d’Asti, Italy 11 38
Riesling 6121 Eroica, Cht. St. Michelle & Dr. Loosen, Columbia Valley, WA 14 50
Pinot Grigio 6125 Jermann, Friuli, Italy 14 50
Jacquere 6150 Jean Perrier, Vin de Savoie, Apremont 12 45
Sauvignon Blanc 6029 Spy Valley, Marlborough, New Zealand 12 45
Chardonnay   Louis Latour, Ardeche, Burgundy 14 50
Pinot Noir 6125 Calera, Central Coast, CA 16 55
Merlot 4005 Trefethen Family Vineyards, Oak Knoll District, California 14 50
Malbec 3008 Waterbrook, Columbia Valley, Washington 16 57
Zinfandel 6125 Dry Creek, Sonoma County 15 52
Tempranillo 1008 Tinto Iturria, Toro, Spain 14 50
Red Blend   Brassfield, “Eruption”, High Valley, Lake County, CA 15 52

Bar Menu

Citrus Smoked Salmon DipCitrus Aioli, Horseradish Creme Fraiche, Caviar, House-Made Potato Chips

Duck Pot StickersCitrus Plum Sauce

House-Cured & Smoked BaconSweet Cherry & Cola Glaze

Crispy CalamariNapa Slaw, Ginger Orange Chili Sauce >

Prime Rib Egg Rolls – Wasabi Aioli, Scallions, White Cheddar, Soy Jus

Tuna TartarChili Ginger, Sesame, Cilantro, Red Onion, Avocado, Crisp Wontons

Peterson’s MeatballsPeterson Family Recipe, Brown Sugar BBQ, Grilled Herb Crostinis

Chef's Cheesesteak - Prime Rib, Smoked Provolone, Caramelized Onion, Roasted Poblano

Peterson's Prime BurgerServed with Peterson's Hand-Cut Fries 

House-Made Truffle Potato Chips - Parmesan Caviar Cream

Breaded Pork TenderloinCider Brined & Applewood Smoked, Spicy Mustard, Lettuce, Pickles

Crispy Chicken SliderHoney Mustard, Pretzel Roll

Shrimp Po' BoyCrispy Fried Shrimp, Lettuce, Tomato, House Remoulade

Prime BurgerHerb Butter, Caramelized Onions

Prime Rib French DipWhite Cheddar, Crispy Onions, Horseradish Cream, Au Jus

Summer SmokeRye, Laphroaig, Giffard Vanilla Liqueur, Angostura Bitters

Warm & Fuzzy – Blanco Tequila, Mezcal, Basil-Jalapeno Syrup, Lime, Grapefruit

Coco MojitoWhite Rum, Hard Truth Toasted Coconut, Mint Syrup, Lime, Pineapple

WisemanhattanThe Wiseman Rye, Averna Amaro, Dolin Vermouth

Peterson's MargaritaBlanco Tequila, Cointreau, Agave Nectar, Orange, Lime

Dream MuleOrange Vodka, Vanilla Giffard, Lemon Juice, Orange Juice

Tropical Thunder - Mt. Gay Eclipse, Chinola Passion Fruit, Hard Truth Toasted Coconut Rum, Black Mint Syrup

Three Broomsticks - Old Forester, Brown Butter, Brown Sugar, Molasses Bitters

Pinetini Our SignatureOrange Vodka, Pineapple Giffard, Pineapple Juice

The Maestro Muddled Serrano & Basil, Silver Tequila, Agave Nectar, Lime Juice

Takes Two to MangoResposado Tequila, Lime, Brown Sugar Cinnamon Syrup, Mango Puree

Gin-Berry- Highclere Castle Gin, Triple Sec, Lemon, Blueberry Juice

Rose Colored Glasses - Lemon Infused Vodka, Triple Sec, Cranberry

Key West - Stoli Vanilla, Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream, Hard Truth Toasted Coconut, Honey Syrup, Rose's Lime

Fishers 75 - Stoli Razberi, St. Germaine, Mint Syrup, Lemon, Strawberry, Prosecco Float

REGIONAL CRAFTS

Bell's Two Hearted IPA

Bell's Kalamazoo Stout

Sun King Osiris Pale Ale

Sun King Sunlight Cream Ale

Sun King Wee Mac Scottish Ale

IMPORTED

Amstel Light Lager

Corona Extra

Heineken

Modelo Especial

Stella Artois

DOMESTIC

Blue Moon

Budweiser

Bud Light

Coors Light

Miller Lite

Michelob Ultra

Rotating Crafts

Single Malt Scotch

Balvenie 12 Yr Double Wood

Balvenie 14 Yr Caribbean Cask

Balvenie 21 Yr Port Wood

Cragganmore 12 Yr

Glenfiddich 12 Yr

Glenlivet 12 Yr

Glenmorangie 25 Yr

Lagavulin 16 Yr

Laphroaig 10 Yr

Macallan 12 Yr

Macallan 18 Yr

Oban 14 Yr

Small Batch Bourbon & Whiskey

1792 Small Batch

Barrell Dovetail

Barrell Vantage

Basil Hayden

Booker's

Bulleit

Castle & Key Small Batch

Castle & Key Restoration Rye

Castle & Key Wheated

Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel

Elijah Craig Barrel Proof

Penelope Architect

Sweetens Cove

Tin Cup 10 Yr

Whistle Pig 10 Yr

Willet Pot Still Reserve

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked

Premium Blended Scotch

Chivas Regal

Johnnie Walker

Black

Blue

Red

Irish Whiskey

Bushmills White Label

Bushmills Single Malt 12 Yr

Tullamore Dew

Cognac & Armagnac 

Courvoisier VSOP

Courvoisier XO

Hennessy XO

Kelt VSOP

Kelt XO

Maison Gelas 8 Yr Selection

Maison Gelas VSOP

Martell Blue Swift VSOP

Remy Martin 1738

Remy Martin VSOP

Remy Martin XO

Ron Zacapa Centenario XO Gran Reserva Especial

Port, Madeira & Sherry 

Graham's Tawny Port 20 Yr

Warre's Otima Port 10 Yr

Taylor Fladgate LBV Port

Taylor Fladgate Ruby

Sandeman 10 Yr Tawny Port

Sandeman Rainwater Madeira

Sandeman Armada Cream Sherry

COFFEE DRINKS

Cafe CocoMalibu Rum, Chocolate Liqueur, Macadamia Nut Liqueur 

"The Dude"Kahlua, White Chocolate Liqueur, Vanilla Vodka

Irish AngelFrangelico, Bailey's Irish Cream  

Peterson's CoffeeNocello, White Chocolate Liqueur

PORT, MADEIRA & SHERRY

Graham's Tawny Port 20 Yr

Warre's Otima Port 10 Yr

Taylor Fladgate LBV Port

Taylor Fladgate Ruby

Sandeman 10 Yr Tawny Port

Sandeman Rainwater Madeira

Sandeman Armada Cream Sherry

DESSERT WINES

Dolce by Far Niente

Inniskillin Ice Wine

Trentadue Chocolate Amore

COGNAC & ARMAGNAC

Courvoisier VSOP

Courvoisier XO

Hennessy XO

Kelt VSOP

Kelt XO

Maison Gelas 8 Yr Selection

Maison Gelas VSOP Bas Armagnac

Martell Blue Swift VSOP

Remy Martin 1738

Remy Martin VSOP

Remy Martin XO

Treat yourself to the best of the top shelf with a luxury pour!

Johnny Walker Odyssey

Johnny Walker’s Odyssey is a rare Triple Malt made from three extraordinary Single Malts. Blended and married together in oak casks to enhance the layering of flavors, Odyssey’s russet-red hue is full of rich tannins. It’s slightly sweet, slightly smoky smooth flavors will linger long after your last sip.

Grand Marnier Quintessence

Grand Marnier’s Quintessence is made from the private reserves of the Marnier Lapostolle family. The most premium offering in the Grande Cuvée Collection, Quintessence is double-distilled with wild tropical orange essence and aged in French oak casks to produce the perfect “quintessential” taste.

Glenmorangie 25 Years Old

The rarest and oldest member of the Glenmorangie family, this is a single malt of notable class and intensity. Full bodied and sumptuous, the Glenmorangie 25 Years Old is the real embodiment of our continued dedication to perfection. Matured in a range of casks including American white oak, Oloroso sherry casks and French Burgundy casks before being blended back together in exact quantities, the Glenmorangie Quarter Century is complex, bursting with deep flavors, and a perfect testimony to our knowledge and experience.